Signature Cakes | Tamara's the Cake Guru - Oshkosh and Appleton

Our New Line of Signature cakes are beautiful choices that can accommodate last minute requests Instead of the 2 weeks required for custom cakes. Order by Wednesday for Saturday-Monday pick up. Order by Saturday AM for Tuesday-Wednesday pick-up and by Tuesday close for Thursday-Friday pick-up.

This line of cakes can be created with less notice. Customize your size, flavor, filling, icing and colors. Add a custom message for any occasion.

*****NEW****** Click for Online ordering which is available for some designs. There are some missing options on it yet, This is new to us, so forgive us as we get it fine tuned, if what you would like is not on the form please feel free to call to order!

We do offer gluten free options for a small upcharge. Please note that we are not a gluten free environment but we have recipes free of gluten and do sanitize. If you have a severe allergy please know we have gluten in the building.

Need it even quicker? We can do cupcakes with less than 24 hours notice, tortes with 3 days notice or Call us to see what we have in our cake cases on Casaloma or in Oshkosh.

Round Cake Designs

7″- $25 base (serves around 8)
8″- $32 base (serves 10-15)
9″- $40 base (serves 15-22)
10″- $50 base (serves 20-28)
12″- $65 base (serves 25-40)
14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

Square Cake Designs (only the cakes pictured in square are available in square and must be fondant covered for signature pricing)

8″ square (serves 15-25) $45 base
9″ square (serves 20-28) $58 base
10″ square (serves 25-35) $75 base
12 sq” (serves 35-50) $90 base
14″sq (serves 50-70) $105

Graduation/college reveal Striped cake $7 art fees

Graduation glitter dots with small hat $5

Buttercream Spring basket Cake Add $5 art fees

Water color Spring Signature Cake Add $5 art fees

Fiona the Fox $5 art fees looks best on a 10″ or smaller

Sweet dots with Fondant elephants Add $12 large elephant $8 small

The cold never bothered me anyway $10 art fees

Ballgame basketball must be 10″ cake add $25 for extra cake and art fees can choose 2 flavors of cake

Holiday Sprinkle Bomb-with or without poinsettia

Gift box cake • 8″ square (serves 15-25) $45 base

Rough iced with colored candies add 1/2 ball cake grad cake $25 (can choose another flavor)

Scrolls with banded school border add $5 rice krispie hat

More than words add Medium rice krispie grad caps $12 art fees

Dude! Add $15 art fees ( turtle is around 6″ large pictured on 7″ cake)

Celebrate square dots and scrolls Fondant only if square

Celebrate the Graduate Add $5 for rice krispie Grad cap large grad hats available by request

Celebrate dots square Fondant only if square

“Take me out to the Ballgame” $15 extra for 1/2 ball cake, can choose 2 flavors and team logo and colors 9″ minimum size on cake

“Scroll Graduation Cake” $5 for Rice Krispie Grad Cap Larger Grad Caps available by request

“All Dressed in White” Add $8-12 depending on gown design

Puppy Love $5 extra for colored icing $10 art fees for puppy and paw prints

“Celebrate” striped bow cake pictured in whipped topping with fondant bow

Rosette cross add $5 for colored icing buttercream or whipped only

“White Winter” pictured in fondant7″- $25 base (serves around 8) 8″- $32 base (serves 10-15) 9″- $40 base (serves 15-22) 10″- $50 base (serves 20-28) 12″- $65 base (serves 25-40) 14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

Ribbon cross pearls $3 Fondant only for square shape

“All dressed in white” add $8-12 for art fees depending on size fondant iced only

“Fall Ruffles” buttercream or whipped topping icing Signature Cake starting at $25

“Pretty Peonies” Add $5 for colored icing $3 for flower

“Monster Cake” •7″- $35 (serves around 8) See signature cake tab for more sizes

Drip Cake Add $5 Customer chooses icing color we load it up with random treats

Dottie- Cake can be iced in whipped or fondant choose dots or stripes or both for pattern, ladybug is covered in fondant. Smaller Rice Krispie ladybug on 9″ or smaller, $12 art fees 10″ or larger has 1/2 ball ladybug cake $25 art

Dottie- Cake can be iced in whipped or fondant, choose dots or stripes or both. ladybug is covered in fondant. Smaller Rice Krispie ladybug on 9″ or smaller, $12 art fees 10″ or larger has 1/2 ball ladybug cake $25 art

Totally Minnie! This cake is only Available starting with a size 10″ cake and up with the hat cake on top. Hat and round cake can be 2 different flavors, This design has an additional fee of $25 on top of base price for extra cake and art fees

Cheers to you pictured in fondant but could be iced in whipped or buttercream

Wally the Whale (add a horn for Narhwal)

“Buttercream Rosettes”add $5 for colored icing Buttercream or whipped topping only

“Sweet Dots” – Fondant covered cake sprinkled in polka dots with a name and age plaque

Celebrate Holiday #2 7″- $25 base (serves around 8) 8″- $32 base (serves 10-15) 9″- $40 base (serves 15-22) 10″- $50 base (serves 20-28) 12″- $65 base (serves 25-40) 14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

“Pintuck with bow ” Must be fondant icing

5″ smash cakes Minnie $20, ladybug $15 Rosettes $10

Glitz and Glamour 7″- $25 base (serves around 8) 8″- $32 base (serves 10-15) 9″- $40 base (serves 15-22) 10″- $50 base (serves 20-28) 12″- $65 base (serves 25-40) 14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

“Stag cake” rough iced with stag silhouette 7″- $25 base (serves around 8) 8″- $32 base (serves 10-15) 9″- $40 base (serves 15-22) 10″- $50 base (serves 20-28) 12″- $65 base (serves 25-40) 14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

Snowflake Cake- fondant Snowman, Elsa and Anna Edible Image or simple Olaf $8 more

Mickey Signature cake #1 Add $25 for Mickey head, smallest cake 10″ can be two cake flavors

Sports drip cake Choose your sports, colors, and jersey number $5 upcharge

Sydney the Sloth Valentine Cake 6″ $30 7″ $35 8″ $42 9″ $50 10″ $60

Cutie Cake Oink Oink with message heart $30

Cutie Cake Olli Octopus $30 with message heart

Base price includes white buttercream, white whipped topping or fondant. Fudge icing, cream cheese icing or colored icings as well as adds $3-8 upcharge.

Two tier signature cakes – 5 days notice (order by Tuesday close for weekend pick-up)

9″ and 6″ serves 25-30 $110

10″ and 7″ serves 30-45 $165

12″ and 8″ serves 50-60 $200