Signature Cakes | Tamara's the Cake Guru - Oshkosh and Appleton

Our New Line of Signature cakes are beautiful choices that can accommodate last minute requests Instead of the 2 weeks required for custom cakes. Order by Wednesday for Saturday-Monday pick up. Order by Saturday AM for Tuesday-Wednesday pick-up and by Tuesday close for Thursday-Friday pick-up.

This line of cakes can be created with less notice. Customize your size, flavor, filling, icing and colors. Add a custom message for any occasion.

We do offer gluten free options for a small upcharge. Please note that we are not a gluten free environment but we have recipes free of gluten and do sanitize. If you have a severe allergy please know we have gluten in the building.

Need it even quicker? We can do cupcakes with less than 24 hours notice, tortes with 3 days notice or Call us to see what we have in our cake cases on Casaloma or in Oshkosh.

Round Cake Designs

7″- $25 base (serves around 8)
8″- $32 base (serves 10-15)
9″- $40 base (serves 15-22)
10″- $50 base (serves 20-28)
12″- $65 base (serves 25-40)
14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)

Square Cake Designs (only the cakes pictured in square are available in square and must be fondant covered for signature pricing)

8″ square (serves 15-25) $45 base
9″ square (serves 20-28) $58 base
10″ square (serves 25-35) $75 base
12 sq” (serves 35-50) $90 base
14″sq (serves 50-70) $105

Base price includes white buttercream, white whipped topping or fondant. Fudge icing, cream cheese icing or colored icings as well as adds $3-8 upcharge. Scroll Down for 2-tier options.

: Sweet Unicorn

: Buttercream blooms

: Buttercream Fireworks!

: The sea $12 art fees

: Buttercream Posies add $5 art fees

: Piped Paisley $5 colored icing

: Swiss dotted garden add $5 art fees

: “Pretty Peonies” Add $5 for colored icing $3 for flower

: “Whimsy” textured icing with sweet ruffle flowers and pearls whipped topping or buttercream icing

: “Buttercream Rosettes”add $5 for colored icing Buttercream or whipped topping only

: “Celebrate dots” jewel tones

: “Funky Dots Celebrate”

: “Monster Cake” Add $10 for colored icing and art fees

: “Sweet Dots” – Fondant covered cake sprinkled in polka dots with a name and age plaque

: “Whimsy” textured icing with sweet ruffle flowers and pearls whipped topping or buttercream icing

: Cheers to you pictured in fondant but could be iced in whipped or buttercream

: “Pintuck with bow ” Must be fondant icing

: “Say it with flowers”

: “Pintuck cross” fondant only

: “Emoji” your choice

: “A spade is a spade” poictured in fondant icing

: Drip Cake Add $5 Customer chooses icing and drip color, we load it up with treats we have in store

: Dottie- Cake can be iced in whipped or fondant, your choice of dots or stripes or both for pattern, ladybug is covered in fondant. Smaller Rice Krispie ladybug on 9″ or smaller, $12 art fees 10″ or larger has 1/2 ball ladybug cake $25 art

: Dottie- Cake can be iced in whipped or fondant, your choice of dots or stripes or both for pattern, ladybug is covered in fondant. Smaller Rice Krispie ladybug on 9″ or smaller, $12 art fees 10″ or larger has 1/2 ball ladybug cake $25 art

: Scrolling blossoms

: “Spring flowers” pictured in fondant

: Summer bouquet pictured in fondant

: Totally Minnie! This cake is only Available starting with a size 10″ cake and up with the hat cake on top. Hat and round cake can be 2 different flavors, This design has an additional fee of $25 on top of base price for extra cake and art fees

: Minnie Mouse smash Add $7

: “Take me out to the Ballgame” $15 extra for 1/2 ball cake, can choose 2 flavors and team logo and colors

: “A spade is a spade”pictured in fondant

: Drip Cake Add $5 Customer chooses icing and drip color, we load it up with treats we have in store whipped topping or buttercream icing

: “Scroll Graduation Cake” $5 for Rice Krispie Grad Cap Larger Grad Caps available by request

: “Fall Ruffles” buttercream or whipped topping icing

: Celebrate the Graduate Add $5 for rice krispie Grad cap large grad hats available by request

: “Sunflower ruffles” $5 extra fudge icing

: “Pastel Ruffles” Buttercream or whipped topping with Fondant Ruffles

: More than words add Medium rice krispie grad caps $12 art fees

: “More than words” bow or flower topper, please provide at least 20 words or more

: “Pintuck bow” square

: Sprinkle Bomb Torte

: “Ruffles” buttercream or whipped topping with fondant ruffles

: “Pintuck Golden Calla lilies” fondant only

: “Celebrate Fun dots” Fudge icing $5 extra

: Googly Monster add $12 art fees

: Funky dots celebrate

: Dotted peony

: “Pintuck bow” your choice of colored bow and beads fondant only

: “Elegance” buttercream or whipped with fondant flower

: Snowflake Holiday Package 2

: “Stag cake” rough iced with stag silhouette

: “White Winter” pictured in fondant

: “Celebrate” striped bow cake pictured in whipped topping with fondant bow

: Rosette cross add $5 for colored icing buttercream or whipped only

: Ribbon cross pearls $3 Fondant only for square shape

: Ribbon cross daisies add $3

: Ribbon cross $3 extra

: Ribbon cross with spring blooms Add $3

: “All dressed in white” add $8-12 for art fees depending on size fondant iced only

: Snowflake Cake- fondant Snowman, Elsa and Anna Edible Image or simple Olaf $8 more

: Celebrate Cross Cake

: Glitz and Glamour-add glittered fondant bow

: “All Dressed in White” Add $8-12 depending on gown design

: Puppy Love $5 extra for colored icing $10 art fees for puppy and paw prints

: Blessed Day

: Carrot cake

: Celebrate baby Add $5 art fees

: Dude! Add $15 art fees ( turtle is around 6″ large pictured on 7″ cake)

: Cookie Monster Add $12 art fees

: Dainty daisies

: Chick chick serves 8-10 $23

: Foo-foo the Bunny $23 serves 8-10

: Rosette cross add $5 for colored icing

: Sweet unicorn

: Celebrate wild child

: Pintuck poinsettia

: Making conversation

: Sweet snowflakes

: Celebrate square dots and scrolls Fondant only if square

: Pintuck corsage (fondant only)

: Celebrate diamonds (fondant only)

: Pintuck bow

: Winter solace

: Celebrate dots square Fondant only if square

: Spring Solace Signature Cake 7″- $25 base (serves around 8) 8″- $32 base (serves 10-15) 9″- $40 base (serves 15-22) 10″- $50 base (serves 20-28) 12″- $65 base (serves 25-40) 14″- $85 base (serves 38-55)